Skip to main content


Just ordered a new phone (Pixel 7), and it's coming first thing in the morning.

Which De-g**gled ROM should I pick?

Please vote AND comment why.

Thanks!

  • CalyxOS (11%, 3 votes)
  • GrapheneOS (48%, 13 votes)
  • /e/OS or iodé (11%, 3 votes)
  • Lineage or other (29%, 8 votes)
27 voters. Poll end: 10 months ago

This entry was edited (10 months ago)
in reply to R. L. Dane :debian: :openbsd:

Calyx had micro g services pre-installed so you get a privacy respecting alternative to Google services instead of just not having them.
in reply to jacob

@jwestall_com

Yeah, I ran Calyx on my 4a 5G and really liked it. I'm kind of interested in trying something new, if only for the experience.

/e/OS looks cool because of its built-in tracker control, and Graphene looks interesting because of its heavy-duty sandboxing.

Unknown parent

@CandyDumDub

How do you handle apps that need google play services?

I never quite understood/bought the argument that running native unprivileged google play is somehow better than MicroG, even if MicroG does run a little stub of google code. %)

But I'm open to it. I've liked #CalyxOS a lot, but I'm interested in trying another ROM that maybe has better sandboxing, or some built-in tracker control like /e/OS

Unknown parent

@CandyDumDub @jwestall_com

I thought it was an objective truth that a single man in possession of a good fortune must be in want of a wife?

Sorry, that's Jane Austen. ;)

Unknown parent

@sirber

Never tried it (30+ years of taking the piss out of Microsoft doesn't go away in a day), but I know that a lot of people were *very* fond of it, more so than windows desktop.

in reply to

@benjamin @CandyDumDub @jwestall_com

Derailed? Nah. Just a detour through sillyspace.

It's kind of like subspace and hyperspace, but with puns. ;)

Unknown parent

@benjamin

We'll fix that yet.

I can send you my backup phone, but it's honestly pretty useless at this point, and has a locked bootloader.

That's a joke I'll never be the punchline of again.

Never buy a phone with a locked bootloader, people. That's like buying a house but not being allowed to paint it.

Unknown parent

@sotolf

Not sure which that would be. I'm guessing Graphene is the quickest on security updates.

Unknown parent

@jungleben

Just curious, how do you handle bad apps like google maps or (eww) WhatsApp?

What's the best way to make sure they don't get any more privileges than they absolutely have to in order to run, and that they can't talk to any other apps on the system to leak info?

I wouldn't be surprised if all the google apps don't collude a whole lot.

Unknown parent

@sotolf

You should try a degoogled ROM some time.

My Pixel 7 is only $450 right now, the same price as the 7a (they're clearing out old stock).
You can get a couple year old pixel for around $300, and it'll still have three years of support. Maybe one extra year if you use the right ROM.

Unknown parent

@sirber

I know. And I'm in too much of a good mood, so I had to flip the tables on you. ;)

Unknown parent

I always you're messing with people, it seems to be your modus operandi. ;)
in reply to R. L. Dane :debian: :openbsd:

huh I can't vote from the phone app lol... but anyways

I use GrapheneOS, I think everything works & there is sandboxed Google Play if I need it. This is a very subjective opinion but this is the only custom OS I have successfully used so... 😂

in reply to Emmie (me)

Experience is just as valuable as a supposedly unbiased opinion.

How do you keep things safe when you have to use apps like google apps or (eww) social apps?

On #CalyxOS, I'd use the work profile, but that's kind of limited.

This entry was edited (10 months ago)
in reply to R. L. Dane :debian: :openbsd:

I... use very few mobile apps, so at the moment none of them uses Gapps

But yeah, GrapheneOS has specifically designed a sandboxed Google Play to deal with those nonsense. Should be safe enough

For me at least the biggest issue is actually downloading the apps in the first place: getting Aurora Store to work properly is a pain, and I don't want to use the official Google Play app

in reply to Emmie (me)

@zlatiah

Yeah, they're fighting an arms race against goog's throttling.

Obtanium can automatically download from apkpure, but I'm not sure I trust that site. :/

Unknown parent

@sotolf

Well, that's fair. If it's still working well for you and you only paid $100 for it, I'd say you've won in every category but privacy, and even there, there's always little things you can do to make things better or worse.
All-or-nothing thinking doesn't help anyone.

You might look at something like the Pocophone for your next purchase. They're usually quite affordable, and supported by at least LineageOS.

...

in reply to R. L. Dane :debian: :openbsd:

@sotolf

...

If you want help finding some good options when you're shopping for another phone (whenever that might be), hit me up.

Also, if you're not using a VPN, look up Tracker Control on F-Droid. It pretends to be a VPN (basically just a loopback tunnel) and can filter out a lot of crap and trackers.

That's what I have right now on my little Nokia.

Unknown parent

@sirber @benjamin

Man, I remember that music video.

I remember my uncle thought the father in that video was hilarious.

Why did you have to take me all the way back to the 80s?!? XD

Unknown parent

@benjamin @sirber

lol, am I behind? I thought I was all caught up!

I try to go through :tl mentions one by one. :tl notifications if I have time.

But sometimes I don't make it down all the way through all of them, and then I just restart from the most recent later.

Unknown parent

in reply to Captain Steph 🇨🇦 :fedora:

@sirber @benjamin

Ummm... Nes. Yo. Umm..

I guess he's saying you're immature, which... if the shoe fits, fill it with shaving cream before you give it to someone to wear.

Unknown parent

@sirber @benjamin

You'd prefer Kermit?

Wait, wait, still reading the first word of your toot.

Ok, done reading the first word.

Now I'm reading the second word.

STOP, still reading the second word.

ok, I'm ready for the third word.

Unknown parent

in reply to R. L. Dane :debian: :openbsd:

@sirber @benjamin

Although, a more faithful description would be like:

while (( data_remaining > 0 )); do
send( pop(data_remaining, a_few_bytes) )
wait_for_ack
done

In contrast ZMODEM would just keep sending data without waiting, but if it didn't receive an ACK within a certain time frame, it would stop and go back.

ZMODEM was very exciting. It meant you could get a lot more done with a mere 1200 baud modem than with Kermit or XMODEM.

in reply to

@benjamin @sirber

Ha, no. very old modem transfer protocol.

Because in the olden days, modems had no error detection, so that had to be done in software, otherwise your transfers could get corrupted.

Unknown parent

@jungleben

How do you handle other apps that require GSF?
Can you install MicroG on Graphene?
I know even a lot of FOSS apps prefer to have some kind of GSF for push notifications, otherwise they have to keep a listener running (like Signal or Element)

It would be nice if you could have more than one work profile. 😁

Unknown parent

@CandyDumDub

Then you're handling it by running GSF, it sounds like.

Unknown parent

@CandyDumDub @jungleben

The storage scopes are pretty neat.

Unknown parent

@CandyDumDub

I think my hesitation with that is that I just don't know what I don't know about what GSF actually does, and the sneaky things it's capable of, even when running unprivileged.

Is it possible to run it only in the work profile?

in reply to

@benjamin

Well, you didn't really lose out on that much 😛 just everything being very slow, and nobody in your house being able to use the phone while you were surfing on the net 😛

@RL_Dane @sirber

in reply to

@sotolf @benjamin
Progressive GIF loading... that's something younger folks will never understand.

There was a certain look to that which you just don't see anymore.

Technically, many JPEGs are loaded progressively, but it doesn't have the same pixelated look, and it usually happens so fast on modern internet speeds that you don't notice.

in reply to R. L. Dane :debian: :openbsd:

@sotolf Actually I put a lot of research into making progressive images, years ago, back when I was on a web performance track trying to cut down every millisecond for loading my sites.
in reply to

@sotolf Also, I used multiple wifi networks this last summer where it made a huge difference to have progressive images on sites I visited, since they were so slow.
in reply to

@benjamin
Slow wifi now is way faster than being on even a fast modem back in the day 😀
in reply to

@sotolf @benjamin
True, but everything is expecting you to have at least 30mbps nowadays.

I actually tried to use the web on a 2G uplink a few years back.

It wasn't slow... it was unusable. Even command-line stuff just timed out.

in reply to El Gordo

@benjamin @sotolf

Almost every kind of modern development is a bit of a joke.

When everything written is huge and sloppy, a couple kilobytes of well-written code can turn the world upside down.

Malware is going to get *HEINOUS* in the coming years.

in reply to El Gordo

@sotolf
I'm a web dev and I have to agree. 😀

's why I made readable.css. https://readable-css.freedomtowrite.org.

Unknown parent

@CandyDumDub

Cool beans. Thanks for the info. 😀

BTW, what happened to the always-on display? I rather liked that. :blobcatderpy:

Unknown parent

This website uses cookies. If you continue browsing this website, you agree to the usage of cookies.