in reply to Evan Prodromou

Fedi by a wide margin, followed by city (only in as much as a city is a collection of people anchored to a place, and not with regard to the actual place or the local government), followed by university (even though I don't have one.)

I have no loyalty to any US political party, although I could conceivably find some loyalty to a syndicalist party if one had any chance of participating in US pol.

in reply to Evan Prodromou

A difficult choice because I hold them all extremely loosely.

Sure, I have some affinity toward my alma mater, but hardly loyalty.

Same with my city, it's a fine town, but my only loyalty is to the friends I have made here, not the city itself. Similarly with my fedi-instance, @stefano does a wonderful job making bsd.cafe a welcoming place, but it's precisely because it would be a non-issue to move to another instance that I remain comfortable here, largely because of the people. If either the tenor of the users/barista changed, there's no particular loyalty to the domain itself.

Political party is the weird one. I've never fit into the shapes of the big parties, so I chose my political party based on the least-unaligned with my values. But my loyalty is to those values, not the party itself, should they change values (glares at what I've witnessed the GOP doing…my Regan-voting ancestors wouldn't recognize the current disaster)

in reply to Evan Prodromou

University: Northwestern. Got a good education there, but no loyalty to them.
assignedmedia.org/breaking-new…

Political party: None.
funcrunch.medium.com/my-gender…

Fediverse instance: @medium. Concerned that they haven't been posting here,* and don't know how long this instance will last.

City: San Francisco, one of the few places in the US I feel *relatively* safe as a queer Black trans person.

* I helped manage this instance briefly as a contractor in 2025; almost no activity since then.

in reply to Evan Prodromou

Definitely not the Fediverse instance.

I'm only using day-wise, then long months not.

The reason? So many people just post complete unproofable things. Or, in other words, factual bullshit.

I also don't have a "Your political party". I like SOME things from almost all german mainstream parties, and I detest SOME things from the same ones. And keep in mind that we have plurality, not a system of two bad parties like in the USA.

In Germany, a university is just a place to study. We don't do such a heckmeck like "MY university", don't do alumin-stuff or t-shirts with uni logos an them. You studied elsewhere? Be my friend!

I moved a lot, so some loyality with a town is an abstract concept to me. Loyality has to be earned IMHO.

So, all in all, your poll didn't make sense to me.

in reply to Evan Prodromou

Pretty partial to kind.social. I feel more at home there than I’ve ever felt in the town I’m in, especially recently, since others here keep electing people who think two of my kids don’t exist.

I’m party-free and have been for a long time. We recently visited our Uni and the state and the entire downtown in the formerly relatively left-leaning city seems to have been taken over by Trump-humpers, so I couldn’t care less about that any longer.

in reply to Evan Prodromou

Nominally, I just picked Fediverse Instance, except that's the one that comes closest, but none of those is the true object of my loyalty. When I gave it a moment of thought, the *loyalty* applies to a human or community of humans. I don't remain "loyal" to an institution or organization in the absence of a higher-order connection to it. Like, if a political party I have supported shifts badly in a direction I can no longer support, the brand is not what'll keep me there.
in reply to Evan Prodromou

I interpret "my political party" a bit differently than most people. I usually don't vote at elections and am not a member of any parliamentary party. I think of the things I most deeply belive in and the values I feel loyal to as my party. Those who join me in those beliefs and values are in that party with me. One of the things that give me the most hope is when I discover how many people there are. Unfortunately, "our" party mostly still needs to be built.
in reply to Evan Prodromou

This is so interesting! My alma mater is closing. My town is the place I spend most of my time, volunteer my time, and occasionally get paid to work here. I do not belong to a political party though I definitely feel loyal about the IDEA of continuing that tradition, and I really like my fediverse instance, and I probably identify the most with them, but I could see belonging to another more than I could see moving.
in reply to Evan Prodromou

city loyalty came pretty high, given fedizens are actually quite proud of their delocalized communities

One of the million ways the fediverse could develop further is every city website upgrades into an instance and locals get an account (if they want 🙈). Technically and economically seems feasible, whether it would be popular and active I have no idea. Occasionally I do hear of proprietary neighborhood oriented platforms, but the only one that made it big in this space was Whatsapp.

This website uses cookies. If you continue browsing this website, you agree to the usage of cookies.