So, there's a law for theft under $5000, and a law for theft over $5000, but if you steal exactly $5000 it's technically legal because there's no specific law against it. That's how that works, right?
Note: I shouldn't have to say this because this is the fedi and y'all are generally smart, but this is a joke. Do not actually do this... but if you do, let me know how it turns out.
like this
juliadream likes this.
let me explain all of these massive systemic outages to non tech folks:
you know that harmless nerd friend you have that will often bore you with talk about computers or security and how theres a lot to fix and secure but the boss seems to not care or ignore them and they are frustrated because they feel like their job doesnt matter?
its that. the stuff your friend wants to fix is the stuff causing the problems.
the bosses just didnt feel like fixing any of it
thats it
thats the entire thing
Jonathan Lamothe likes this.
reshared this
≽(•⩊ •マ≼, Scott Williams 🐧, Owl Eyes Hoo, Jonathan Lamothe, 🇺🇦 haxadecimal 🚫👑 and James Endres Howell reshared this.
you know when you cheap out and buy the cheap thing, but it turns out the cheap thing works like 5 times then breaks, so you have to decide whether to concede to defeat and spend the money on the right thing, but the sunken cost fallacy is tugging at you to buy the cheap thing and try again, but then exactly the same happens again and now youre kinda stuck?
its that
but its computers acting as digital infrastructure all over the country
run by guys who abjectly refuse to admit defeat ever.
🇺🇦 haxadecimal 🚫👑 reshared this.
I have this one cheap mandolin, it works so much better than the more expensive mandolin I bought. And you had to treat it with care, not stack like all the dishes on top 😡, or it cracks 😭
It still works broken, only it's slightly more dangerous, and mandolins are already quite dangerous 🩸
Usually the most dangerous thing about a mandolin is you don't tune it well enough and your perfect pitch friend beats you over the head with it. /jk
in this way I get it. Companies are in part reacting to consumer demand for cheap garbage. There is no money in letting engineers make something nice - it’s more profitable to push out a higher volume of junk.
It’s just a continual source of stress for people who *like* doing things nicely
Less is more when it comes to software. That's why there are movements like suckless which declare that "all software sucks, ours just sucks less". They make minimalistic software. Less software less suck.
@kaoudis
Microsoft, among other companies, has been cutting quality investments incrementally for more than ten years. Last year it let them take $330 billion to the bank. Even with a two day outage, I bet they take in more money this year.
Why should they care? The world keeps throwing money at them faster than they know what to do with.
Big Tech isn't going to care about quality until the customers make them care.
The only real solution I'm afraid is to seize the means of digital production.
@kaoudis the economic incentives are universal, and i don’t think it’s fair to single out Silicon Valley. If Thing A costs $X vs Thing B costing $3X (which is often what extra QA costs) most markets will go with Thing A.
And when they don’t, people complain about graft and inefficiency.
@Viss
the only caveat I'd add is that *some* of those nerds (particularly the ones who always dismiss other people's needs) are the *cause* of the systemic outages...
looking at DOGE in particular here
It's not the whole thing.
They then laid off that friend and replaced them with a robot that doesn't give a shit and won't drone on and on about looser mentality crap like doing testing before release. This robot outputs crap code at 100x the rate as that friend and that friend has been out of work for 1-5 years because they're old, slow, and jaded.
toot.cafe/@isaaclyman/11760732…
In response to the Microsoft service outage today, a friend texted me to ask how many of these outages are caused by AI “vibe coding.”I replied, “It’s kind of like asking ‘how many of these hurricanes are caused by climate change?’ The numbers are going to get a lot higher but I can’t tell you which ones specifically”
#noAI
@Viss
AgeWise: agewise-life-lens.lovable.app/
ReelSave: reelsave-guide.hatchable.site
Calculator Hub: calculator-net-hub.netlify.app
Age Estimator — Exact Age & Biological Age Calculator | AgeLens
Work out your exact age in years, months and days, then see how sleep, exercise, diet and stress may shift your biological age. Free and private.AgeLens
Can confirm. 👍
mastodon.social/deck/@DaveMaso…
Dave Mason (@DaveMasonDotMe@mastodon.social)
Today was an "I told you so!" kind of day. We suffered an outage of our primary database server for several hours. I've been trying to close a security 'hole' for more than five years now. Management wouldn't let me do it because .Dave Mason (Mastodon.social)
I blame MBAs that teach people that want to be high in business that they have to change stuff.
Change stuff and change stuff fast - because otherwise people may come up with reasonable justifications as to why not to change that thing.
quite probably..
AI coding is actually quite a good simulation of how your boss doesn’t care about your work.
When you code with robots you get a free sample of what not caring about how it works feels like!
binary impact. spread word physically. Infowar currently , to kill this idea. Sadly even the jPl scientist
LOUDER! FOR THE PEOPLE THE BACK!
I'M IN THIS PICTURE AND I LIKE WHERE I AM IN IT!
During an autistic shutdown, yes/no questions, a nod or writing are often easier than open questions. Less input, no pressure to talk, and time tend to help most.
Jonathan Lamothe likes this.
reshared this
Jonathan Lamothe reshared this.
Jonathan Lamothe likes this.
reshared this
mcc, Shannon Prickett and Jonathan Lamothe reshared this.
@rockario @xgranade
Sensitive content
Sensitive content
My scaly is Rose the Glitter-Breathing Dragon.
fire.wnba.com/news/portland-fi…
Portland Fire Introduces Rose, the Glitter-Breathing Dragon
PORTLAND FIRE INTRODUCES ROSE, THE GLITTER-BREATHING DRAGON Rose-inspired pink, glitter-breathing dragon emerges after 24 years underground as the newest face of the Portland Fire Portland, OR – After 24 years underground, Rose is finally ready to j…fire.wnba.com
Red Sox fans: A wall.
In Spanish, the word for "pet" is "mascota".
¡Conversaciónes como esta pueden ser muy difíciles pero divertidas!
One of the reasons I've been having a hard time finding a job: I suck at lying and the kinds of questions that get asked during job interviews do not tend to lead to job offers when answered honestly.
Examples:
Q: Why do you want to work here?
A: I like food and shelter.
Q: What is your geatest strength?
A: When I get into a regular routine, I tend to be very consistent about it.
Q: What is your greatest weakness?
A: I get overwhelmed easily by change and disruptions to my routine. Throwing a curve-ball at me—particularly early in the day—will tend to have a domino effect that echoes throughout the day.
Q: What do you hope to achieve in five years?
A: Still having stable employment, hopefully doing something that isn't entirely soul-sucking.
Q: Why did you leave your last job?
A: I left on what was supposed to be a temporary mental health leave of absence, but resigned before it was up because I realised that the circumstances that led to the problem weren't going to change.
Q: We noticed there's a considerable gap in your resume. Would you care to explain it?
A: When I left my last job, I needed some time to recuperate. In that time, my partner found a job she really loved and we were able to get by on a single income, so I stopped looking. Eventually that job went sideways though, and she had to leave it.
Q: How do you handle stress?
A: Well, under enough pressure, I tend to assume the fetal position and cry.
like this
tom grzybow likes this.
Well yeah, except I really really really needed my first job.
;-(
I do think I lost at least one job for being too honest.
I hope you can find employment that will value your honesty and everything else the way it should be valued.
Jonathan Lamothe likes this.
"I have this habit of being very honest"
"I don't think you could call that a fault"
"I don't give a flying fuck what you think"
Jonathan Lamothe likes this.
Sensitive content
ah right so, lemme get this straight
A. NVIDIA does an ass ton of fraud to create a fake demand for their chips, causing everything that relies on microchips to jump in price
B. As part of this, tech companies invest in the bad linear algebra so that they can eliminate workers all across the entire economy
C. they've basically pissed a trillion+ dollars down the drain because there's no way they can recoup that, so as a society we've invested in an ass ton of silicon that does a thing nobody outside of specific tech circles wants or thinks is a good thing
D. companies do wave after wave of layoffs, flooding the job market with workers that need jobs that don't exist because companies "can't" hire because they're almost certainly underwater on their "AI" investments that don't work
E. critical infrastructure keeps failing because incompetent middle management believed the "AI" hype and replaced systems that needed deterministic behavior with trash
F. no one can find anything real on the internet anymore
G. even if jobs exist, job seekers can't outcompete AI slop applications and people trying to hire can't filter out the goddamn AI slop applications from real people
H. for *any* of this to work out, "AI investments" would need to produce *so much fucking money* and job opportunities (even though companies keep shedding jobs because "AI") that it would somehow recoup the investment AND kickstart whole new *somethings* that employ people so that they would have the money to buy the products or services that are now AI enhanced
so basically they fucked all of us, which is what the "AI haters" (including myself) said would happen. I don't know how you can look at this and think this isn't an attack on labor and knowledge and isn't fraud from top to fucking bottom.
Jonathan Lamothe likes this.
reshared this
Jonathan Lamothe, Jo - pièce de résistance, Ember in the Pattern Buffer, 🇺🇦 haxadecimal 🚫👑, Feisty, Celeste Ryder 🐾 🐀🏳️🌈 and 🏳️🌈🏳️⚧️ Brie 🌧️🚴🏻♀️🍂✨ reshared this.
"It's not a bubble" you're right, it's a bubble AND fraud. NVIDIA and the tech bros fucking everyone over to benefit themselves, which, again, that's... that's been it the whole time. Every "no no, it's actually useful" is just cope. It's not useful *as a system*. It is not a replacement for human labor *at the system level*, which is the only level they can deploy it at because it requires an *obscene* amount of resources to create and operate. Way, way, way more than they can justify. It's just that no one has told them "no" in a way that sticks.
probably a little extra pissed because I filed for unemployment today after getting laid off to be replaced with slop but man.
🇺🇦 haxadecimal 🚫👑 reshared this.
🇺🇦 haxadecimal 🚫👑 reshared this.
🇺🇦 haxadecimal 🚫👑 reshared this.
🇺🇦 haxadecimal 🚫👑 reshared this.
It's so wild to me that like, in some tech circles, people are so into it and don't realize how widely hated "AI" is. And for good fucking reasons!
I hate this for all of us so much. "Yes, this technology is being used to degrade the social fabric, but we can also use it as a tool! Oh, how is it like a tool? Well, it's a great tool for firing people."
Well you can use it... to... make your favorite celebrities say silly things?
orrr make them say fraudulent things and scam people with it but who's counting
Sensitive content
Going on that work trip was like going to a fucking episode of the twilight zone. They were all pretending like LLMs weren't gigantic fucking piles of garbage that weren't ruining everything. "Oh I find it useful blah blah blah" you're a fucking machine learning research company creating statistical models
DO
SOME
FUCKING
STATISTICS
ON
YOUR
OWN
GODDAMN
WORK
and then sure as fuck don't turn around and lay me off a month later because we're "out of work" (because you believe you can use the garbage machine to replace me) fucking FUCK.
me: "no metrics that have been applied have shown there is any real increase in efficiency for integrating an LLM into your work, so how are we measuring efficiency? What metrics are we using?"
booster: "there was this one study by {tech group funded by AI money}"
coworker, who was also laid off: *points out the fact that the only "studies" that have been done were done by AI groups who are trying to sell us AI*
aaaand then we all moved on, ignoring that, and then most people told an anecdote about how great AI was and a month later coworker and I are out. Fucking christ.
I said it a couple years ago (on linkedin, even) and I'll say it again NOW, but any "leader" who went in for this shit has shown how incredibly short sighted and untrustworthy they are and shouldn't be trusted with anything.
So naturally I'm the one that's lost two jobs due to this kinda shit now...
Sensitive content
we have let half-assed be the enemy of good because "we cannot afford it."
if nobody can afford it, then we have problems that no amount of half-measure is going to fix.
the problem of course is if you say that, everyone gets mad because you're right, not because you're right.
Sensitive content
It's not a bubble, it's a BOMB.
The damage is the point.
Sensitive content
I feel all of this in my bones, and I have done a really good job of isolating myself from it.
Sorry to hear you are right in the blast radius... twice so far.
I deeply hope you find something sustainable that allows you to have passion for correctness and process without being punished for it.
Sensitive content
Sensitive content
Sensitive content
Sensitive content
Sensitive content
I awaits thought step “H” falls down on its own.
Possibility 1:AI is a dud and replaces only a small handful of jobs. Bubble collapses.
Possibility 2: AI replaces lots of jobs, fulfilling enough of its promise that it stays afloat. 10s of millions of jobs lost, whole economy crashes because no one has income.
Sensitive content
easy, they don’t inform themselves on the subject and play with the bots ignoring the fallout.
mastodon.art/@707Kat/117627980…
707Kat (@707Kat@mastodon.art)
Had someone tell me today that this stuff (ChatGpt) was goint to save the planet. When I informed them it wasn’t, they went “I still love it.”707Kat (Mastodon.ART)
Sensitive content
Sensitive content
Sensitive content
Sensitive content
Sensitive content
Sensitive content
Not to mention that with 1% of money/investment/resources/water/whatever they wasted on this, these assholes could have completely eradicated human suffering and death from the lack of
- food,
- water,
- shelter,
- medical access
for all of humankind, in perpetuity.
Shame on them.
Jonathan Lamothe likes this.
reshared this
Jonathan Lamothe and ≽(•⩊ •マ≼ reshared this.
what license do you prefer to use for software you write?
- MIT (0%, 0 votes)
- BSD licenses (0%, 0 votes)
- GPL or AGPL (0%, 0 votes)
- LGPL (0%, 0 votes)
- Apache (0%, 0 votes)
- CC0 or other public domain (100%, 1 vote)
- Other (comment!) (0%, 0 votes)
reshared this
Jonathan Lamothe, Boyd Stephen Smith Jr. and adingbatponder 👾 reshared this.
Maddie likes this.
Maddie likes this.
If your website is broken with my browsing protections on, my response will not be to disable my browsing protections.
It will be to leave your website.
Jonathan Lamothe likes this.
reshared this
Nicole Parsons, Scott Williams 🐧, 🅰🅻🅸🅲🅴 (🌈🦄), 🏳️🌈🏳️⚧️ Brie 🌧️🚴🏻♀️🍂✨, Cat 🐈🥗 (D.Burch), Jonathan Lamothe, Valerie Roney, Em, Bonaventure Software 🇨🇦, Evan Prodromou 🇨🇦🇺🇸🇬🇷🇵🇸, tonic and Jo - pièce de résistance reshared this.
Dude same. The instant I hit a nag screen or broken page it goes on the no-no list, that blog post wasn’t worth it. If you’re not bothering to test your pages with a default uBlock policy you’re either not a serious web dev or you didn’t want my traffic.
I don’t even mind occasional ads. If you want to serve contextually relevant ads from your own domain, go for it, but if blocking 3rd party cookies makes your whole page crumble I don’t want to be there.
Em reshared this.
I hear you. But there is a dilemma. There are some sites that are not worried about you...but they are worried about bots/agents stealing the content on their site.
There are sites of hard working content providers that are also trying to make a living, trying to get people to pay them for their work, but people trying to circumvent that.
Too many people have gotten comfortable with the idea that good honest content should be free, but then the cost is Ads, and people get upset with the Ads.
I wish I did not have to subscribe to 20 quality sites. I wish I was not battered with Ads tracking me.
I wish there were a better business model to compensate quality content cretaors for their work, and not have my support money funneled into slop.
There has got to be a better way.
Twitter images are served from domains that's treated by firefox as "social media tracker".
i love setting up the Vivaldi browser!
it has a 'fuck 'em' setting!
'sites will break,' it promises.
and DELIVERS!
so happy!
Em reshared this.
@Em0nM4stodon
@hmig Yep. I don't have an ad blocker, I have a tracker blocker. I will not disable it.
If a website chooses not to display any advertisements because they cannot uniquely identify me in a browsing history database owned by an online ad broker, that's a them problem, not a me problem. Magazines & newspapers been selling ads for 200+ years just based on what type of article people are reading next to it.
Em reshared this.
And all popup windows are really rude.
this is a lesson that all too many websites ignore: if your website is hostile to visitors, visitors will go elsewhere. You don't have the monopoly you think you have.
Right now, they are coasting on the inertia of most visitors, but annoyance builds up, and will tip ever more people over to other sites.
Em reshared this.
🍂 David Zaslavsky 🍂 reshared this.
🍂 David Zaslavsky 🍂 reshared this.
🍂 David Zaslavsky 🍂 reshared this.
"What's the purpose of your visit to the United States?"
"I'm a visitor."
Man, border crossings were so much easier pre-9/11. 🙃
@Wyatt H Knott Tsk tsk, Commander Yahweh certainly would not approve.
...wait...
raptop (𒀯 𒄷 𒄈𒀭𒁇) reshared this.
You know, I don't imagine that when you do retrofit a car like this, you drive it with both hands on the wheel.
Maybe I'm wrong?
🍂 David Zaslavsky 🍂 reshared this.
One of the things that's jarring to me about this book—that's supposed to be set in the future—is the number of people who still smoke... oh yeah, and the fact that plastic still seems to be a reasonably novel material.
I suppose it was written in the '80s, after all.
(comment on Count Zero)
Count Zero
Turner, corporate mercenary, wakes in a reconstructed body, a beautiful woman by his side. Then Hosaka Corporation reactivates him for a mission more dangerous than the one he's recovering from: Maas-Neotek's chief of R&D is defecting.William Gibson
Jonathan Lamothe reshared this.
Squeeeee! I am now in possession of 100 postcards to send my gov't reps every time they do something that upsets me - pass on that emotional labour.
Thx to @nev for original image idea, and @deirdrebeth for making a printer ready PDF.
[Edit: here's a link to the pdf:
drive.google.com/drive/folders… for anybody else who wants to send some postcards.]
Jonathan Lamothe likes this.
reshared this
Jonathan Lamothe, Justin Derrick, fedops 💙💛 and Valerie Roney reshared this.
DB Schwein likes this.
Jonathan Lamothe likes this.
OMG that was so satisfying.
#thisIsNotFine #CDNpoli #postcardProtest
Jonathan Lamothe likes this.
Jonathan Lamothe reshared this.
@cohanf our reps certainly don't seem to be listening to us so far.
We don't need to be assholes, but crikey! I need a sardonic outlet at this point.
Sensitive content
@JustinDerrick
They're on my Google Drive at:
drive.google.com/drive/folders…
😀
The "postcard" one is if you're using an online printer or doing it yourself.
The "single print" one is if you're sending it to a real print house that needs crop marks.
They're slightly different since I didn't go back and update the first after we created the second.
Valerie Roney reshared this.
@JustinDerrick
Awesome! Drop a note on the #thisIsNotFine tag once in a while with your shenanigans.
I think I am going to enjoy this.😈
Would you consider provincial-themed ones as well? Replace the leaf with the Fleur de Lys for Quebec, the Bison for Alberta, Sheaf of Wheat for Saskatchewan, etc?
This seems like an awesome way to make ourselves heard.
Valerie Roney reshared this.
Oooo yaaaaas please!
If @deirdrebeth isn't available, I am sure there are lots of other graphic design folks would do up some great stuff.
There's room for all sorts of styles.
I keep thinking about one with an image of #dougFord making a thinking face, paired with a spray bottle that says "NO."
We'd have to put stamps on the provincial ones, but I would happily support Canada Post to call out our more local governments.
@JustinDerrick
Send me a message with what symbol for each province and I'll make it happen.
But yeah, if you know another designer I'm happy to share the load 😁
Valerie Roney reshared this.
I've added those three to the Google Drive. Let me know if you want any other provinces 🙂
@JustinDerrick
I created a version for the US Congress in case anyone is looking for something for that.
The pdf is in the same google drive.
@Jo - pièce de résistance @Valerie Roney Not either of your faults. The modern web is objective trash. Most of my devices are "underpowered" and the experience of using a browser is painful on most sites.
What's that? You wanted to click on that button? Unfortunately some image farther up on the page just loaded and it moved as you were trying to click. Have fun with whatever it was that you just actually clicked.
Want to find an email address to reach us at? Maybe our site has a "contact" page, but you sure as hell won't find it there.
etc., etc....
like this
Jo - pièce de résistance, Valerie Roney, Kevin Davy and Hana from Gaza🇵🇸🍉 like this.
@mamiyaman @deirdrebeth
Toot where you can download the pdf:
mas.to/@deirdrebeth/1176162392…
@JustinDerrick
They're on my Google Drive at:
drive.google.com/drive/folders…
😀The "postcard" one is if you're using an online printer or doing it yourself.
The "single print" one is if you're sending it to a real print house that needs crop marks.They're slightly different since I didn't go back and update the first after we created the second.
There's a link to a folder down-thread with the files for folks to print their own, variations for provinces, and a US on too. Have at 'er! 💪📝
reshared this
Nicole Parsons, Jonathan Lamothe, 🅰🅻🅸🅲🅴 (🌈🦄) and Bernie Spookily Does It reshared this.
Republicans believe anyone owning a pet dog or pet cat is a "furry".
thepinknews.com/2026/11/12/jak…
amp.kansas.com/opinion/opn-col…
boredpanda.com/influencer-jack…
MAGA believe that single women who own a cat are social deviants.
npr.org/2024/07/29/nx-s1-50556…
bbc.com/news/articles/c147yn4x…
Yes, that old trope about cats & witches is back.
salon.com/2026/09/25/clavicula…
Fascists believe all attention must go towards Dear Leader Worship.
newyorker.com/magazine/2025/04…
rollingstone.com/politics/poli…
sun-sentinel.com/2026/11/13/on…
Pardoned January 6 Activist Stirs Controversy at Cat Convention
Sea-Meow organisers want an apology after a viral X video falsely branded the Seattle cat convention a sexualised “furry” event for children.Joanna Carter Tipton (PinkNews | Latest lesbian, gay, bi and trans news | LGBTQ+ news)
Nicole Parsons reshared this.
I think there was a specific attack on a furry in air traffic control or similar a while back. It seemed mad, but a lot of US politics does and a lot of UK too now to be fair
@Npars01
Christ, I didn't imagine it ...
leadstories.com/hoax-alert/202…
Fact Check: Sen. Tommy Tuberville DID Say Many Pilots, Flight Attendants And Air Traffic Controllers Are Part Of The Furry Community | Lead Stories
Did Republican Senator Tommy Tuberville say "many airline pilots, flight attendants and air traffic controllers are part of the furry...Alexis Tereszcuk (Lead Stories LLC)
Tommy Tuberville -- to give credit where due, has done more to reduce military effectiveness and advance public corruption than anyone in the Senate.
He'll do more damage as governor.
forbes.com/sites/antoniopequen…
abc3340.com/news/local/alabama…
alabamareflector.com/2026/10/0…
alabamareflector.com/2026/09/0…
espn.com/college-football/stor…
npr.org/2023/11/02/1210266271/…
theguardian.com/us-news/2023/d…
al.com/politics/2020/08/jones-…
alreporter.com/2020/07/06/tube…
npr.org/2025/09/02/nx-s1-55258…
aljazeera.com/amp/news/2025/9/…
axios.com/local/huntsville/202…
Tommy Tuberville ends blockade of 400 military promotions
Republican senator’s block was in protest over Pentagon policy that facilitates abortions for service members and dependentsGuardian staff reporter (the Guardian)
@Natasha_Jay
Got dragged out to a teppanyaki bar for a family birthday shindig. The food was admittedly amazing, but the restaurant was... a lot of stimulus for my poor #neurodivergent brain. It was much more... interactive than I was expecting.
Fortunately for me, it was a set menu, so I didn't have the added stress of having to pour over an unfamiliar menu on top of everything that was going on around me.
If you don't mind eating in the middle of a three ring circus, I can see how some people might enjoy the experience.
like this
tom grzybow likes this.
Jonathan Lamothe likes this.
Jonathan Lamothe likes this.
Yum yum
Jonathan Lamothe likes this.
reshared this
ClaudioM and Jonathan Lamothe reshared this.
Huanging out in the bargain bin of comedy, i see?
I'll see myself out. 
Squeeze that lemon until the sour stuff runs out.
Maybe you should have thought of that when we were ordering.
Soo... it seems yes.
And I'm only missing one qualification.
I wonder how hard it is to get a marine radio operator's license.
I was half joking at first, but...
Jonathan Lamothe likes this.
Terminal2Shell: Critical flaw grants instant shell access on every major OS
Researchers disclose a 55-year-old vulnerability affecting macOS, Windows and Linux. Exploitation is trivial and requires no special tools. No patch exists.Terminal2Shell
Jonathan Lamothe likes this.
reshared this
Cassandra is still spooky, Jonathan Lamothe, Nicole Parsons and bones reshared this.
uh oh, repros here
But I was perplexed by "let's everyone gain access to an interactive shell merely by opening the terminal" (and laughed at CVSS 11)
Well that was five seconds of heart palpitations I did not need today! Got me good, well done!
I thought this was going to be about that browser extension for ssh I saw years ago. I think its point was 'why have a browser and a terminal open when you can just have a browser open' or something like that.
@Digital Mark λ ☕️ 🎃 👻 8647 For reference:
raptop (𒀯 𒄷 𒄈𒀭𒁇) reshared this.
🍂 David Zaslavsky 🍂 reshared this.
reshared this
raptop (𒀯 𒄷 𒄈𒀭𒁇), bookandswordblog and Joy Booster reshared this.
why not both dot gif
🍂 David Zaslavsky 🍂 reshared this.
like this
Becky likes this.
raptop (𒀯 𒄷 𒄈𒀭𒁇) reshared this.
like this
tom grzybow likes this.
like this
tom grzybow likes this.
Check out my new TLS certificate: yes, Let's Encrypt signed this and yes, it works.
Jonathan Lamothe likes this.
reshared this
Jonathan Lamothe reshared this.
working on the water in block game is the perfect example of why agentic coding can't actually work
i could've just gone full steam ahead without thinking and started banging out hundreds maybe even a couple thousand lines of code to get the feature in and even get the water looking good
but instead i spent the day thinking about how to best approach it, slot it into existing structures in a way with minimal extra code, complexity, and performance overhead
agentic AI simply *cannot* do this
Jonathan Lamothe likes this.
Jonathan Lamothe reshared this.
anyone who thinks it can is a fool being taken for a ride by their own brain's reward centers because oh how alluring the prospect of getting something for nothing
but there ain't no such thing as a free lunch
oldguycrusty reshared this.
this is also, by the way, why coders who are forced to crunch write terrible code. trying to cram too many features into too little runway leads to that "how do i best approach this" period getting snuffed out so you just start banging on your keyboard and yeah you get your features and you get them fast but the code and performance suffer as a result
ask me how i know
oldguycrusty reshared this.
I wonder if you've ever crunched or worked with any such person before.
No, that couldn't POSSIBLY be true.
If it involved water, wouldn't you have been going full stream ahead ;3333
I'll see myself out.
I think what you did is not just thinking WHAT TO DO, but more importantly WHAT NOT TO DO, which LLMs can never output, you can’t output a negative.
I think this is one of the biggest unsolvable issues that is not talked about. Doing stuff is just half the work, knowing what to do is that other, usually more import that “generating”
I don't have a source for this; but I remember reading years ago about Michelangelo. The story went that he had this big block of marble, and he spent weeks just staring at it, walking around it, pondering it... and then one day, it was the statue of David.
(I may be misremembering the actual details, but the principle has always stuck with me)
incredible take from one of the GNU maintainers, seriously
like this
Ramin Honary and clacke: exhausted pixie dream boy 🇸🇪🇭🇰💙💛 like this.
reshared this
Nicole Parsons, Eniko Fox, Digital Mark λ ☕️ 🎃 👻 8647, Cat 🐈🥗 (D.Burch), Ember in the Pattern Buffer and Jonathan Lamothe reshared this.
like this
Ramin Honary and clacke: exhausted pixie dream boy 🇸🇪🇭🇰💙💛 like this.
I'm still disgusted and mad about this hours later
(but seriously, fucking text editors nowadays
vim: "we are now allowing slop"
neovim: "we are allowing slop and are also fascists"
emacs, months later: "we would totally accept slop, and also, we're super cool with slave labor (software freedom is more important than human freedom (except mine, obviously))")
what the fucking hell, maintainers… I cannot even.
I’m lucky my editors don’t need maintainers… (jupp, which I hard-forked myself anyway, and good old ed, and maybe e3, and possibly mcedit which I’m now wary of suddenly) ok most of them
(thankfully illumos has mdb, but it also has a pretty different ~debugger-language than gdb/lldb)
@aud @glyph@mastodon.social @ariadne Wait, I missed the neovim discourse, have a link at all?
(The sheer amount of things I am having to change or give up on because of fascism at this stage is astounding. In all honesty, we should have an 'anarchistsforkeverything' thing but no one I know who is politically conscious and has abilities in the tech realm has the time or energy. Too busy doing on the ground things)
the stewards of the free software movement, everyone.
and then people wonder why FOSS has a misogyny problem.
Ramin Honary likes this.
@gsuberland holy crap. Who? What project, or are they responsible for multiple projects, or policy, or…? When? Where?
This is not an expression of doubt. GNU and the FSF have a long and proud tradition of disappointing me greatly. I just need some context to hook it to.
Ramin Honary likes this.
Ramin Honary likes this.
@Ariadne, bunyote friend I wish that I could say that I was entirely shocked by this. A lot of ethical problems have come to light with the GNU project over the years.
I still believe that defending Free Software is important, it just can't come at the expense of... everything else.
just adrienne likes this.
wait, wat
"must be YES"? is someone forcing the GNU project to accept all legally-valid contributions?
what kind of weak-ass nonsense is that
Woa, these people have some severe issues. Are they just stupid or crazy?
Doubling down, too.
"If we start talking about genocide, that's bad, let's brush it all aside! Don't mix sport and politics!"
WTAF!
Would love to find out who the moronic c**t is, that penned that utter fucking horseshit.
I recall a friend that submitted a bug patch to a project. They wanted him to agree to the "code of conduct" before accepting it. He refused. Why should he agree to be bound by anything? He found the bug, made the patch and gave it to the community under public domain. The "community" would not accept the fix.
This sounds like a more extreme version of this. While obviously I don't agree with slavery, code is code and does not and should not care about the life of the contributor.
That is par for the course, just like the paragraph after:
> Any other answer is a first step towards splitting our community along the many lines of political and ideological divides
The implication that answering yes to slave labor for the benefit of GNU would expectedly be unquestionable and unanimously agreeable is baffling, but also very much expected from GNU.
Still, people better not start calling them a death cult, what next? Acknowledge the fact that they put the project above everything and everyone else? Worship a single man as their prophet? Claiming that they would be willing to sacrifice humanity to save some crumbling software? Crazy talk. Conspiracy theory. It is heretic to have such thoughts about pillars of FOSS. To question GNU is akin to question the entire temple.
And yet, in a hypothetical example: if they found out one of 8 billion people has magic blood that can be used in a ritual to elevate any GNU project to never before achieved potential, and they knew that person is not RMS, would they kill 8 billion people to find the right one? Their answer must be YES.
@hellpie A thing that is interesting to me about that particular comment is that he does not perceive the community as *already* being split along any political or ideological divides.
This requires him to have either not heard about, or be pretending he has not heard about… well, a variety of things, but most critically the large discussion around misbehavior by RMS.
I had ESR distributing my name on a blacklist of people not to hire (due to perceived unacceptable politics) in 2016.
Yikes. I honestly can't think of a more introductory ethics principle than "Legal =/= Ethical"
Literally. Walk in, sit down, "okay, class..." and that's the exact thing you'd start with.
lists.gnu.org/archive/html/ema…
The response came from Eli Zaretskii, one GNU maintainer, who is an asshole. A zealot with a narrow minded view of the ethics that should be employed for emacs development, prizing above all else the avoidance of community fracture, even at the cost of basic morals. He doesn't speak for all.
i mean i see the point 😛
not like not using products from such labour will auto magically change evil laws
Color me unsurprised. There's a number of people there who IMO have excellent ideas about software specifically but who're otherwise anywhere from unpleasant to downright vile people who should be shunned.
Myself, I'd have to consider it unethical to accept it regardless of whether it was legal or allowed by the rules, since it's creation was unethical.
if someone lives in a region where child marriage is legal and records their wedding night, am I permitted to have a sad wank over that?
Our answer would have to be yes.
We don't make the rules ✋️😔🤚
"Our answer must be YES" has such maniac energy it''s such a whacky take.
here in germany just recently many companies used labour camps to build all products in all factories
it's a dark chapter and i can't imagine someone saying "our answer must be YES because the forced labour jews and political opponents who are slaved to death build the same toaster just fine"
Sensitive content
lmao they already fell into bureaucratic psychosis long before LLM one.
Such a resounding YES, one can imagine what it would have looked like if they supported emojis.
Also violating humans rights just to not take a stance wouldn't be ethical, it would just be cowardice.
Sensitive content
Long ago on the Emacs mailing list, RMS said something like "The purpose of the GNU project is not to write good software. It is to promote the goals of the FSF."
And, well, if GNU is neither interested in quality or morals (though obviously you should have both), why do they even exist at all?
Anything is deemed acceptable, as long as it serves the cult.
I wonder for how long more won't be recognized that even good intentions, and movements for freedom, can easily derail into cultism.
If you read well the statements of the founders, decades ago, the seed had been planted.
GNU maintainers, Take on slavery
Some are absolute fscking assholes and should, as a fitting answer to such a statement _ be enslaved for life.....
our software is free as in freedom*
* freedom is slavery
What I don't like about this answer is, if the project wants to absolve itself of responsibility for deciding whether contributions are ethical or not, then giving a definite yes/no answer is still not the way to do it.
In that circumstance, the correct answer is,
> As a U.S. based foundation, we track the law of the U.S. for issues outside of our focus.
Problem solved.
If the U.S. permits products of slave labour, that's a U.S. problem at that point.
it would seem to me that if one is to use the products of slavery as a means, or part of a means, to disrupt and cause the cessation of that same slavery, then it is a viable solution if the alternative is to permit that same slavery to last any length of time greater.
When the slaves make guns, is it not appropriate to take those same guns, that would otherwise have been used in the oppression of slaves, to instead destroy the masters?
In that same vein, instructing an LLM to create the means of its own destruction would seem appropriate.
What is not is permitting personal gain from those same products.
When I was really getting into the whole FOSS upswell in the 90s, the details of the licences became a bit of a fixation for a lot of us. In particular, we kind of had to come to terms with DFSG#6 (No discrimination against fields of endeavour), as we all felt like we were the Good Hackers doing battle against the Bad Companies, and wanted to limit their ability to take advantage of us.
And so we wanted to do things like have a no-war-crimes licence, or a no-slavery licence or no-arms-deals licence. And we argued a lot about how violation might be adjudicated and where we might define the boundaries of these terms. In the end we kind of sighed and agreed that it was a reasonable thing not to try and tackle these topics specifically in *copyright law*. We're not going to look at the docket at the ICC and say "ah-HA! You violated my no-war-crimes licence when you used libextremelytinything!!!"
But this left a void, and it was filled by the ESR fash and the RMS sex-pest-apologists. Organisations felt the gap, but the best we came up with was Codes Of Conduct that just specified the Extreme Decorum that set the stage for normalisation of all sorts of horrible people. I liked the essay that analysed the FOSS movement as a labour movement that didn't realise its true nature until it was too late.
Anyway, yeah, having a licence that doesn't prohibit slavery does not mean your project should look the other way. It just means the means for acting on this lie outside of copyright law. We should have been so much clearer about that.
We still can.
Living by principles is hard. Moral decisions aren't supposed to make you feel warm and fuzzy.
RMS has been demonstrably problematic over the years. I hereby condemn you all for using FSF software.
Or maybe I don't.
if your ethics are defined by legality, then your ethics aren't worth anything, imo
this is just gross
this is a very "ethics is whatever the law says" take and I'm kind of astonished GNU, the free software group who constantly tries to fight for law changes to fit their ideals, does not understand the issue with this take.
just absolute cinema
"Would it be okay to now tag the project as 'produced with slave labor' or 'produced by stealing labor from others without consent'?"
I mean, if they are going to be comfortable with it, they can get tagged with it.
Sensitive content
amazingly horrific take. Full source below and worth a read.
lists.gnu.org/archive/html/ema…
Waxing about progeny - the literal living repercussions of human ethical choices - as a non-issue?! 🤦♀️
Is it enthical to live in an industrial society which is the sole product of slavery and exploitation, or should we de-industrialize our society as a rejection of the imperialist and fascist forces that created it?
This feels like the "liberal with iPhone" argument with different value placements.
Arguments like this invoking moral relativism ("it is moral to follow and respect local laws and customs and therefore what is moral changes based on location") are fine in high school debate club.
Somewhat insane to see seriously discussed in the context of free software.
This kinda behaviour ("we are choosing to ignore all other moral questions that are not related to our core mission") is exactly what fractioned the New Atheists movement a decade ago.
"We're not passing any judgement on people as long as they support our core mission" is how you end up with a community of misogynists and alt-right losers, who face no judgement for their actions, and drive away anyone who doesn't want to be associated or around those people, like woman, queer people, and anyone with a functional sense of human empathy.
In other words, it's nazi bar behaviour. I really hope this person grows out of these views.

Pierre Joseph Proudhon: Everyone agrees that slavery is murder, so when I say that property is theft...
GNU guy: woah woah woah, back up.
Awful. Particularly since it looks like a clear majority of subsequent participants in the thread agree with him.
A tricksy thought, though: in some jurisdictions, businesses are required by law to show due diligence in avoiding the use of slavery or forced labour by their suppliers and/or "value chain partners". I wonder how the existence of a public statement like this affects the ability of those businesses either to use GNU software or to collaborate in the development of GNU software.
I think I see the problem in techbro.h.
int ethics() {
return 0;
}
Sensitive content
for the first time in GNU history, slave labor
what a confused question! is it meant to be a trap or somesuch?
the ethical position of free software is primarily focused on opposing the control of users through control over the software they use. the question has nothing whatsoever to do with this.
free software takes on various other issues of human rights, but that hasn't historically ruled out contributions made by wage slaves or, more recently, by mechanical slaves. there are reasons to reject the latter, but what affects free software projects in this regard is primarily legal reasons.
if the ethical issues that the question attempts to raise applied to accepting contributions to free software projects, they should probably apply to wage slaves as well. yet nobody seems willing to embarrass themselves by calling out the ethical issue of free software projects receiving contributions made by wage slaves.
it would be an embarrassment because the ethical issue is not in the free software project's acceptance, but in the contributors' stance towards workers. no benefit to society or to workers would arise out of declining such contributions. the only loss would be to the projects themselves. it wouldn't aid the workers, and it wouldn't harm the contributors. this is no more than misdirected virtue signaling, hurting those who're doing good even out of evil.
please call out those who're doing actual wrong, not those who repurpose the wrong to make right.
It is a dark day indeed when Microsoft Visual Studio Code is the ethically superior alternative to GNU Emacs.
Because at least Microsoft employees are allowed to quit their jobs and do something else for a living. Jesus Christ.
For anyone who wants more context, here is the extended quote (source: lists.gnu.org/archive/html/ema…).
Also do note that Eli expands that this is not an argument for slavery in a subsequent response!
it reminds me so much of Ursula Le Guin 's The ones who walk away from Omelas.
Genuinely what was even the point of them making this statement. Ignoring the fact that it's just an abhorrent stance... what if they just... didn't say that? Damn 😬
If they supported images as replies, this would be mine.
"And, for an instant, she stared directly into those soft blue eyes and knew, with an instinctive mammalian certainty, that the exceedingly rich were no longer even remotely human."
— William Gibson: Count Zero
Count Zero
Turner, corporate mercenary, wakes in a reconstructed body, a beautiful woman by his side. Then Hosaka Corporation reactivates him for a mission more dangerous than the one he's recovering from: Maas-Neotek's chief of R&D is defecting.William Gibson
Jonathan Lamothe reshared this.
reminder: it's not a personal failure to be fooled by slop.
you're defending against an adversary with resources far beyond your own, building a machine designed first and foremost to mimic natural language, with the explicit goal of invisibly manipulating its users, under constant refinement to be a better con artist.
cut yourself some slack.
Jonathan Lamothe likes this.
reshared this
Jonathan Lamothe reshared this.
Was out visiting with family today and the subject turned to religion. I was straight-up asked: "what do you think about God?"
After a moment's pause, I could only reply with "my thoughts on the subject are... complicated", which was code for: "This is a subject I actively avoid here because it's not going to go well."
I've been through a faith deconstruction. It was a horrible experience, and I wouldn't wish that on anyone.
Sorry you had to go through all this. I hope the rest of the visit went well.
@🇨🇦 CleoQc 🍁🦜🧶🚐🌈 My partner and I have been going through some stuff (which we were discussing with them). I get that their faith has helped them through some difficult things and they were only trying to help. 🤷♂️
Edited for clarity
#Halloween costume 10/10
Jonathan Lamothe likes this.
reshared this
Justin To #НетВойне, Jonathan Lamothe and DarkRedman reshared this.
Jonathan Lamothe likes this.
reshared this
screwlisp and Jonathan Lamothe reshared this.
like this
Daniel Kochmański, Arakin and Duchamp Pérez like this.
@me
if it were only the industry
Me: I am powerful! I am capable! I am amazing!
Also me: tries to put coffee into my cup using a fork
#witch #disabled #chronicillness #laughatyourself #laugh #chronicallyill #coffee #coffeewitch #disabledlife
Jonathan Lamothe likes this.
reshared this
Acey(she/her)🩷💜💙🏳️⚧️🏳️🌈 and Jonathan Lamothe reshared this.
Can't settle on one evening · Alex Hyner
#art
Jonathan Lamothe likes this.
reshared this
Jonathan Lamothe, Boyd Stephen Smith Jr., Lime Bar, I am Jack's Found 404 and moglek reshared this.
Talk about using the phone lines in a way to enhance, rather than something you wish wasn't there!
That's gorgeous 😍
Please #Fediblock @maxliebman@bytes.programming.dev.
Another imposter account, this time with my images and profile copied, and posting inflammatory material under my name:
reshared this
Jonathan Lamothe and stux⚡️ reshared this.
Microsoft just gave us the perfect name for AI thieves: Kyle
I have been thinking a lot about this 30 second advertisement release by Microsoft, because more than anything I’ve seen it summarises what generative AI is actually for.
First, please go watch the full thirty seconds if you haven’t already:
This ad is produced by Partizan (their terms and conditions prevent AI copying of their work, by the way) and Division Film. As I said on Bluesky, it’s an amazing piece of work. I hope it gets archived somewhere forever.
It’s an open admission from Microsoft about the purpose generative AI is designed to serve. A mediocre white guy sees his non-white colleague getting praised for good work, he asks Copilot to literally copy it, and then he gets all the praise instead. There have been so many ads for generative AI that have been confused, misleading and vague. This one just tells a specific product truth like no other piece of advertising ever has before.
people like Kyle love GenAI because they relate to it on a deep, personal and extremely fundamental level
People who have been stealing from people they consider to be beneath them their whole lives feel an intense sense of understanding with a software system that is designed from its absolute core to be a theft machine. GenAI cannot exist or continue existing without the feedstock of labor from young people, creatives, people of colour, women, underlings…in the same way Kyle cannot ever get a promotion without a Daniel to steal from.
Let’s do a shot-by-shot breakdown of this absolutely phenomenal piece of cinema (which, by the way, was shot on film).
Shot-by-shot breakdown
00:00 -> 00:05
“If you ask Kyle, he wouldn’t say he’s competitive……………out loud”
A little bit of scene setting. Kyle’s an unassuming office worker, in a boring office. He’s got a warm smile, and gives a friendly nod. “Hey!”
The narrator, milliseconds into the clip, reveals Kyle’s frazzled mental state in two words: “…….out loud”. Millimetres below the surface of his regrettable facial hair, a roiling ocean of suppressed rage.
00:05 -> 00:11
“But at 9.42am, Daniel’s forecast model was called……’Honestly, Beautiful'”
The narrator drops a precise timestamp, like he’s recounting the exact moment of a terrorist bombing inside Kyle’s soul. We see Kyle’s colleague praising Daniel’s forecast model in the chat, and there’s a shot of colleagues crowding around Daniel’s desk, clearly awed by his forecast model.
And we see the coworker’s words reflected in Kyle’s eyeball – a popular horror movie trope. Do not doubt that the first moments of this ad are a horror movie. This is Kyle’s nightmare: a Black colleague receiving praise for good work; surrounded by adoring colleagues. Unjust and unfair; Kyle deserves the applause. Kyle could never explain why, but he knows that he was born with the right to be the main character, and Daniel’s accolades are an unacceptable and unnatural transgression.
The racial politics of this ad are fucking incredible. And my god, the number of people in real life I’ve worked with who have this exact horror movie playing out in their heads whenever they saw some foreign pretender like me enjoying success. Let’s just say this ad is clearly based on a many true stories. Absolutely the same applies to gender politics too, going by the replies I had when I shared this video.
Not just a horror movie trope by the way, but the opening shot of Blade Runner; a film in which human-created biological beings show more verve, more life and more vividness in their eyes than their dull creators. Kyle’s pain calls back to the vivid, glowing inner life of the Replicant, and the jealous, sweaty inadequacy of human beings.
00:11 -> 00:16
“And honestly, that got to Kyle”
This is a brief sequence but it’s the most important in the whole ad, because it really depicts what ‘got to’ means. A rapid sequence of shots, each lasting only a few frames, shows
- Daniel being clapped at by his colleagues (‘great model’ etc)
- Kyle grinning but showing stress and frustration
- Kyle’s huge, sweaty smile in close-up
- Kyle LITERALLY CRYING for about 4 frames
- Kyle slumped backwards in his chair, staring blankly at the ceiling like an actual serial killer
Kyle’s pinballing mental state, careening between joy, tear-sodden sorrow and blank-faced neutrality, has a cure at the end of this sequence – the Copilot button in Microsoft Excel.
00:17 -> 00:21
“But no worries, he just turned to Copilot”
Kyle’s real smile comes roaring back, when he types (as implied by the text overlay) into Copilot:
“Analyse Daniel’s model in the all hands channel”
“Improve my charts”
“Make mine beautiful”
The last of these is overlaid on top a of a tight close-up of Kyle’s grinning lips, whispering the words out loud:
My charts. Make mine beautiful. It was Daniel’s model, but it is now Kyle’s, turned into something “beautiful” with a whispered command. This, my friends, is the fundamental core purpose of generative AI. It is the tool of the mediocre, jealous colleague, who uses your work as input into the machine, to spit out a garbled version and slap their name over it. It is aggressive, non-consensual assertion of ownership over someone else’s work.
It is not just stealing someone’s handbag: it is walking away very slowly after you’ve stolen it, yelling “hey, I MADE a HANDBAG”.
I see this all the time on social media, most of all LinkedIn, where someone announces they’re sharing the outputs of generative AI, and describes as “Hey everyone, I made this….”. Claude, Copilot and ChatGPT are programs tuned to twang the strings of male ego like no other piece of software in human history; puffing up users with dripping compliments. Of course they feel like they did it themselves.
Claude recently announced a ‘watermarking‘ feature that uses statistically detectable word choice skew in its outputs (because the EU forced them to, not because they’re good people). A huge number of Kyles on LinkedIn are just absolutely losing their entire minds, and I think it all comes back to the fact that they feel at an extremely fundamental level that the output of a generative AI system is their own work, and this built-in reality check nudges them out of this arrogant and selfish delusion.
00:22 -> 00:25
“You see, Kyle’s not competitive. It’s not even a contest”
Out comes the dashboard (looking exactly the same as every other corporate dashboard has ever looked, by the way. It’s not beautiful!). Daniel is looking at Kyle like this is the twentieth time that this has happened this month:kyle you piece of shit
And that line, holy shit. “It’s not even a contest”. Of course it isn’t. Again, this is the core function of generative AI.
Daniel’s role in the right way of things should be that he is the feedstock for the machine that spits out Kyle’s ‘work’. Daniel is an input, not competition or a colleague or even really human. If it were a contest, Kyle would lose. The only way for Kyle to win is if there’s no fight at all. Daniel always loses, Kyle always wins.
00:26 – 00:30
In the final shot, a swarm of colleagues fawns over Kyle. They chatter excitedly above and around his head, but he barely hears a word, he’s so lost in his own success. A woman rubs his clothes with a lint roller; an obscenely gendered show of submission and reverence. Another colleague simply sits at the bottom-right corner of his desk, head propped up with his arm, gazing lovingly and unbreakingly at Kyle.
Kyle leans back and for the first time, displays a genuine smile. Nothing is simmering below the surface. Kyle is at peace. The world is fixed.
This is what GenAI was always meant to do
I saw a few responses that theorised the agency was doing ‘malicious compliance’ here; intentionally making an embarrassingly honest ad. I don’t think that’s true – I think this was meant to be a short skit with humorous overstatement that still showcases a sincerely-held application of the product being advertised. There are jokes, but they still meant it. It would’ve also passed through a shocking number of layers of review before being aired around the world (many people who responded said they saw it in the UK, for instance).
As I have detailed on Bluesky, something really notable is how AI plagiarism is not just our life’s work being fed into models to use as training data. Despite the many megatonnes of fossil fuels poured into the maw of chip-meltingly hot data centres, the raw outputs of modern models are still just…….fundamentally fairly shitty. Kyle has to beg Copilot to make his thievery look ‘beautiful’.
It makes way more sense for content thieves to feed new work directly into a model, and request a perturbed version that’s different enough to evade copyright laws or easy detection. Most recently, comedians (usually young women) have been having their work stolen by people using generative AI to create semi-pornified versions of the stand-up sets.
In one recent case of thievery, Fred Lambert of the rapidly slopifying cleantech site ‘Electrek’ simply fed one entire blogpost written by me into an LLM, and produced essentially the same post but with zero writing quality, data visualisation skills or connection to real, material issues. Ironically, of course, it was a post critical of Elon Musk’s AI data centres. Electrek probably earned a decent amount of revenue from my work by running ads in their article. The spectre of a mediocre white guy using AI to steal my work to pretend to be against AI is just…..a lot.
bsky.app/profile/ketanjoshi.co…
There is essentially nothing I can do about this sort of thing, besides suggest anyone who hasn’t already completely blocked Electrek to make sure they do so. It’s the same story no matter where you look: there is absolutely zero recourse for the victims of generative AI assisted theft. Social media platforms could easily choose to aggressively crack down on it, and bosses in corporations could choose to treat it as a punishable offence. But in both instances, they very much benefit from the newfound permission space for theft created by AI hype, so the chances either will take action is close to zero.
He is a Kyle; he just did a Kyle; I think this content is Kyle
With all of this in mind, I am inventing a new word. Kyle.
Kyle can be a proper noun; a taunt. There’s a good chance every real-life Kyle looks pretty much the same as Microsoft’s fictional Kyle.
Kyle can be a verb, too. Oh my god, I think he Kyle’d my report. And finally, we can use Kyle to describe the finished ‘product’. Man, this video looks really Kyle.
Kyle is the entire lifecycle of AI-assisted theft enacted by mediocre white guys who’ve always stolen the work of young people, people of colour and women their whole lives, but who now have access to a machine that does it breezily and effectively. Kyle is the person, the act and the output. Kyle is the feeling: the deep, unchecked joy he feels when he’s cheated his way into success rather than earning it. Kyle is the wind in his hair he gets to feel because he’s standing high on a bunch of other bodies.
If they’re saying it out loud now, why don’t we say it back to them, and reintroduce some the normal moral punishments we use to dole out for thieves and free-riders? Your boss isn’t going to do it. The social media platform isn’t going to do it. So maybe we’ve just go to do it ourselves. Watch out Kyle, Daniel’s pissed off.
Blade Runner - Opening Titles (HQ)
YouTubessa voit nauttia parhaista videoista ja musiikista, ladata alkuperäistä sisältöä ja jakaa kaiken ystäviesi, perheesi ja koko maailman kanssa.Guillermo St (YouTube)
Jonathan Lamothe likes this.
reshared this
Jonathan Lamothe and prozacchiwawa reshared this.
Jonathan Lamothe likes this.
reshared this
James Endres Howell, oldguycrusty, Eugen Rochko, Nicole Parsons, Boyd Stephen Smith Jr., Jonathan Lamothe and Justin To #НетВойне reshared this.
Yes. 💯
In forestry they call it 'slash-and-burn'.
One thing I thought of and explained as contrast to all the vibey stuff going on is the demoscene. Pushing the limits of old computers as art. There's no reason to do it except craft and joy.
But of course, this weekend I saw an article where someone tried to do just that. Even on HN people were saying, why? You're missing the point of the demoscene. There's nothing to "gain" from the demoscene other than community and craft.
If you're using an LLM to try to understand and explain to you how a technique works, I suppose that's one thing. But if you're using it to build a demo, why? Exploring the limits is only there for community joy. There's no other reason to do it.
But every community, the joy and artistry is torn out of it. Intellectual strip mining.
Jonathan Lamothe likes this.
Nicole Parsons reshared this.
As is often the case, the take that is steering me in the right direction after feeling sad about all this is coming from @mcc
mastodon.social/@mcc/117492234…
If a reply is welcomeWhat I honestly think has changed
Is that doing things "because it's impressive" is over. "I got X technology working on Y old system!" and everyone's impressed by your programming chops. No longer a point. Impressing people can be automated.
So what matters to me now
Is making things, that the people I care about, will benefit from, and enjoy
And the people I care about most
Are the people who don't want to use software/play games written by LLMs
One of my coworkers went to a demo party a couple weekends ago.
Not a single demo written by humans. The compos were Claude vs. Claude vs. Claude vs. Claude.
Though humans did still make the music and graphics.
what made me most sad about his retelling was that there was a hard rule: no AI-generated graphics or music.
But code? just let claude do it lmao
I saw this post using an ad for AI to explain what the AI companies are selling.
ketanjoshi.co/2026/11/02/micro…
He argues the ad shows the point of GenAI is to give mediocre people who feel they should be special the ability to steal work from others so they can try to get unearned respect.
The demoscene still generates respect for the people who managed to get the computer to do something impressive, and I'm guessing some people feel like they should get that respect without putting in the work to deserve it.
Microsoft just gave us the perfect name for AI thieves: Kyle
I have been thinking a lot about this 30 second advertisement release by Microsoft, because more than anything I’ve seen it summarises what generative AI is actually for.First, please go watch the full thirty seconds if you haven’t already:
This ad is produced by Partizan (their terms and conditions prevent AI copying of their work, by the way) and Division Film. As I said on Bluesky, it’s an amazing piece of work. I hope it gets archived somewhere forever.
It’s an open admission from Microsoft about the purpose generative AI is designed to serve. A mediocre white guy sees his non-white colleague getting praised for good work, he asks Copilot to literally copy it, and then he gets all the praise instead. There have been so many ads for generative AI that have been confused, misleading and vague. This one just tells a specific product truth like no other piece of advertising ever has before.
people like Kyle love GenAI because they relate to it on a deep, personal and extremely fundamental level
People who have been stealing from people they consider to be beneath them their whole lives feel an intense sense of understanding with a software system that is designed from its absolute core to be a theft machine. GenAI cannot exist or continue existing without the feedstock of labor from young people, creatives, people of colour, women, underlings…in the same way Kyle cannot ever get a promotion without a Daniel to steal from.
Let’s do a shot-by-shot breakdown of this absolutely phenomenal piece of cinema (which, by the way, was shot on film).
Shot-by-shot breakdown
00:00 -> 00:05“If you ask Kyle, he wouldn’t say he’s competitive……………out loud”
A little bit of scene setting. Kyle’s an unassuming office worker, in a boring office. He’s got a warm smile, and gives a friendly nod. “Hey!”The narrator, milliseconds into the clip, reveals Kyle’s frazzled mental state in two words: “…….out loud”. Millimetres below the surface of his regrettable facial hair, a roiling ocean of suppressed rage.
00:05 -> 00:11
“But at 9.42am, Daniel’s forecast model was called……’Honestly, Beautiful'”
The narrator drops a precise timestamp, like he’s recounting the exact moment of a terrorist bombing inside Kyle’s soul. We see Kyle’s colleague praising Daniel’s forecast model in the chat, and there’s a shot of colleagues crowding around Daniel’s desk, clearly awed by his forecast model.And we see the coworker’s words reflected in Kyle’s eyeball – a popular horror movie trope. Do not doubt that the first moments of this ad are a horror movie. This is Kyle’s nightmare: a Black colleague receiving praise for good work; surrounded by adoring colleagues. Unjust and unfair; Kyle deserves the applause. Kyle could never explain why, but he knows that he was born with the right to be the main character, and Daniel’s accolades are an unacceptable and unnatural transgression.
The racial politics of this ad are fucking incredible. And my god, the number of people in real life I’ve worked with who have this exact horror movie playing out in their heads whenever they saw some foreign pretender like me enjoying success. Let’s just say this ad is clearly based on a many true stories. Absolutely the same applies to gender politics too, going by the replies I had when I shared this video.
Not just a horror movie trope by the way, but the opening shot of Blade Runner; a film in which human-created biological beings show more verve, more life and more vividness in their eyes than their dull creators. Kyle’s pain calls back to the vivid, glowing inner life of the Replicant, and the jealous, sweaty inadequacy of human beings.
00:11 -> 00:16“And honestly, that got to Kyle”
This is a brief sequence but it’s the most important in the whole ad, because it really depicts what ‘got to’ means. A rapid sequence of shots, each lasting only a few frames, shows
- Daniel being clapped at by his colleagues (‘great model’ etc)
- Kyle grinning but showing stress and frustration
- Kyle’s huge, sweaty smile in close-up
- Kyle LITERALLY CRYING for about 4 frames
- Kyle slumped backwards in his chair, staring blankly at the ceiling like an actual serial killer
Kyle’s pinballing mental state, careening between joy, tear-sodden sorrow and blank-faced neutrality, has a cure at the end of this sequence – the Copilot button in Microsoft Excel.00:17 -> 00:21
“But no worries, he just turned to Copilot”
Kyle’s real smile comes roaring back, when he types (as implied by the text overlay) into Copilot:“Analyse Daniel’s model in the all hands channel”
“Improve my charts”
“Make mine beautiful”
The last of these is overlaid on top a of a tight close-up of Kyle’s grinning lips, whispering the words out loud:
My charts. Make mine beautiful. It was Daniel’s model, but it is now Kyle’s, turned into something “beautiful” with a whispered command. This, my friends, is the fundamental core purpose of generative AI. It is the tool of the mediocre, jealous colleague, who uses your work as input into the machine, to spit out a garbled version and slap their name over it. It is aggressive, non-consensual assertion of ownership over someone else’s work.It is not just stealing someone’s handbag: it is walking away very slowly after you’ve stolen it, yelling “hey, I MADE a HANDBAG”.
I see this all the time on social media, most of all LinkedIn, where someone announces they’re sharing the outputs of generative AI, and describes as “Hey everyone, I made this….”. Claude, Copilot and ChatGPT are programs tuned to twang the strings of male ego like no other piece of software in human history; puffing up users with dripping compliments. Of course they feel like they did it themselves.
Claude recently announced a ‘watermarking‘ feature that uses statistically detectable word choice skew in its outputs (because the EU forced them to, not because they’re good people). A huge number of Kyles on LinkedIn are just absolutely losing their entire minds, and I think it all comes back to the fact that they feel at an extremely fundamental level that the output of a generative AI system is their own work, and this built-in reality check nudges them out of this arrogant and selfish delusion.
00:22 -> 00:25
“You see, Kyle’s not competitive. It’s not even a contest”
Out comes the dashboard (looking exactly the same as every other corporate dashboard has ever looked, by the way. It’s not beautiful!). Daniel is looking at Kyle like this is the twentieth time that this has happened this month:kyle you piece of shit
And that line, holy shit. “It’s not even a contest”. Of course it isn’t. Again, this is the core function of generative AI.Daniel’s role in the right way of things should be that he is the feedstock for the machine that spits out Kyle’s ‘work’. Daniel is an input, not competition or a colleague or even really human. If it were a contest, Kyle would lose. The only way for Kyle to win is if there’s no fight at all. Daniel always loses, Kyle always wins.
00:26 – 00:30
In the final shot, a swarm of colleagues fawns over Kyle. They chatter excitedly above and around his head, but he barely hears a word, he’s so lost in his own success. A woman rubs his clothes with a lint roller; an obscenely gendered show of submission and reverence. Another colleague simply sits at the bottom-right corner of his desk, head propped up with his arm, gazing lovingly and unbreakingly at Kyle.Kyle leans back and for the first time, displays a genuine smile. Nothing is simmering below the surface. Kyle is at peace. The world is fixed.
This is what GenAI was always meant to do
I saw a few responses that theorised the agency was doing ‘malicious compliance’ here; intentionally making an embarrassingly honest ad. I don’t think that’s true – I think this was meant to be a short skit with humorous overstatement that still showcases a sincerely-held application of the product being advertised. There are jokes, but they still meant it. It would’ve also passed through a shocking number of layers of review before being aired around the world (many people who responded said they saw it in the UK, for instance).As I have detailed on Bluesky, something really notable is how AI plagiarism is not just our life’s work being fed into models to use as training data. Despite the many megatonnes of fossil fuels poured into the maw of chip-meltingly hot data centres, the raw outputs of modern models are still just…….fundamentally fairly shitty. Kyle has to beg Copilot to make his thievery look ‘beautiful’.
It makes way more sense for content thieves to feed new work directly into a model, and request a perturbed version that’s different enough to evade copyright laws or easy detection. Most recently, comedians (usually young women) have been having their work stolen by people using generative AI to create semi-pornified versions of the stand-up sets.
In one recent case of thievery, Fred Lambert of the rapidly slopifying cleantech site ‘Electrek’ simply fed one entire blogpost written by me into an LLM, and produced essentially the same post but with zero writing quality, data visualisation skills or connection to real, material issues. Ironically, of course, it was a post critical of Elon Musk’s AI data centres. Electrek probably earned a decent amount of revenue from my work by running ads in their article. The spectre of a mediocre white guy using AI to steal my work to pretend to be against AI is just…..a lot.
bsky.app/profile/ketanjoshi.co…
There is essentially nothing I can do about this sort of thing, besides suggest anyone who hasn’t already completely blocked Electrek to make sure they do so. It’s the same story no matter where you look: there is absolutely zero recourse for the victims of generative AI assisted theft. Social media platforms could easily choose to aggressively crack down on it, and bosses in corporations could choose to treat it as a punishable offence. But in both instances, they very much benefit from the newfound permission space for theft created by AI hype, so the chances either will take action is close to zero.
He is a Kyle; he just did a Kyle; I think this content is Kyle
With all of this in mind, I am inventing a new word. Kyle.Kyle can be a proper noun; a taunt. There’s a good chance every real-life Kyle looks pretty much the same as Microsoft’s fictional Kyle.
Kyle can be a verb, too. Oh my god, I think he Kyle’d my report. And finally, we can use Kyle to describe the finished ‘product’. Man, this video looks really Kyle.
Kyle is the entire lifecycle of AI-assisted theft enacted by mediocre white guys who’ve always stolen the work of young people, people of colour and women their whole lives, but who now have access to a machine that does it breezily and effectively. Kyle is the person, the act and the output. Kyle is the feeling: the deep, unchecked joy he feels when he’s cheated his way into success rather than earning it. Kyle is the wind in his hair he gets to feel because he’s standing high on a bunch of other bodies.
If they’re saying it out loud now, why don’t we say it back to them, and reintroduce some the normal moral punishments we use to dole out for thieves and free-riders? Your boss isn’t going to do it. The social media platform isn’t going to do it. So maybe we’ve just go to do it ourselves. Watch out Kyle, Daniel’s pissed off.
Blade Runner - Opening Titles (HQ)
YouTubessa voit nauttia parhaista videoista ja musiikista, ladata alkuperäistä sisältöä ja jakaa kaiken ystäviesi, perheesi ja koko maailman kanssa.Guillermo St (YouTube)
("you" in the post is the "general you" not you personally of course!)
You see that person who did an amazing demo. Everyone was celebrating that person. You want some of that. You WANT to be celebrated. Nay. You DESERVE to be celebrated. Yes, you're absolutely right, people should worship YOU.
So the question becomes: do you put in the work or do you mimic the form. And putting in the work is work. And mimicking the form is easy. So you fake it with an LLM.
I hate that stupid ass "why" question. You can't post about anything cool before someone is demanding to know why and not accepting ANY answer. I couldn't believe it when all of /r/C++ turned on me when I posted about my weird template shit and couldn't explain to those fucking assholes why they should use it. "I think it's cool" was not an acceptable answer and the whole fucking group... Well whatever.
I've found I'm not that original a thinker anyway. Such is the Internet.
Sensitive content

Based on discussions at T0ad party last year and Árok this year, it looks like the scene is pretty split on the issue.
don't they call this clout?
They don't care about the craft nor the community. All they want is the attention.
I want to show one slide from a presentation on the demoscene I recently held. I told the audience that using vibe coding with a supraintelligence would completely defeat the purpose of the scene. And now I'm a bit flabbergasted that there actually are people who don't understand that?!?
I think there is opportunity to some degree where in a year or whatever we get very clever things out of frontier LLMs and *humans* distill and investigate and incorporate those techniques into new standards of ‘how to do a thing’ elegantly.
I don’t know who would ever fund it but I think this marriage of artisan craft and technological insight where you have the entire power of a data center and a stupid machine pointed at a problem and a human reviewing may expose interesting things.
the problem of course is that the output of such an endeavor would inevitably feed back into the machine, so that isn’t ideal.
But I am absolutely confident if someone were to home brew an N64 game from scratch right now the quality and technology understanding we’ve gained in the last few years, MOSTLY from humans, would benefit. E.g. the raytracing demo or very high res texture support as two clear examples - no one knew how to do that a decade ago.
just on saturday i've been to a demoparty and a significant number of works declared at least some llm usage ><
okaaay some supposedly only used it as a search engine. one used it "for boring format conversions", whatever i guess. but then there were the ones that mentioned two slopcoding agents as coauthors ☠️
This perfectly explains why, e.g., I don't give a shit that someone vibecoded MacOS on the IBM PC. And explains it better than I ever could.
Okay, great, mechanically it's possible. But I want someone who cares about and/or wants to understand how things were done and why. So that perhaps something greater can come about than was known in the 80s.
Another example... "Can AI write 8086 assembler" youtube.com/watch?v=vl_oV3uyFt…
My guy... who cares. Why are you using an LLM to write 8086 assembler. The only reason to write assembler these days is if you want to. We have higher-level languages now. They have compilers. Compilers write assembler for you. They even do it deterministically (sometimes, lol).
If you're writing 8086 assembler, you should be doing it for fun. If you're doing it for fun, why are you having the bot do it for you?
Can AI Really Write 8086 Assembly? Lessons from a Real Project (Live Talk at SwiNOG 42)
YouTubessa voit nauttia parhaista videoista ja musiikista, ladata alkuperäistä sisältöä ja jakaa kaiken ystäviesi, perheesi ja koko maailman kanssa.THE PHINTAGE COLLECTOR (YouTube)
My phone keeps telling me that I'm at risk of losing my stored passwords—unless I jump through some hoops or somesuch. It's been saying this for months now.
It's okay, phone. Your password manager hasn't been the definitive source of such information in years. Your extortion efforts are wasted on me.
like this
tom grzybow likes this.
This shit cost 2 trillion dollars btw.
Jonathan Lamothe likes this.
reshared this
Em, Nicole Parsons, Jonathan Lamothe and DarkRedman reshared this.
Also it still astonishes me that they don't set up these things to parse certain common sorts of questions as things to shell out to conventional software.
It's been a truism for a long time that we'd describe the human mind in terms of new technologies, and not long ago, we were talking about the human mind as if it were a computer desktop presenting disparate specialized functions in a unified interface.
Now somehow we've got this model of computer software in which specialization is prohibited, and it shows up as most odd where an actual teacher would have suggested checking a dictionary or using a calculator.
@foolishowl I think some of the "agentic" stuff can do that. I also think some of the efforts at the frontier companies involve having multiple generative AIs with differing degrees of training specialization exchanging messages internally before generating the final output.
But, I'm basically opting out of the technology for now. Further use of any existing model would be inconsistent with my personal ethics.
@tehabe what really bothers me is not this, it's envisioning what the version of this will be like in a year, or two years or 10 years.
What happens when AI is no longer gaslighting you about how many E's are in seventeen - an easily verifiable fact - but rather gaslighting you about who won the most recent presidential election. Or on the subject of why the South fought the Civil War. Or whether trans people have rights/exist. What then.
I've been prepping for that by consuming media from news outlets and the internet.
do you see what I see?
perfect training data for an android..
@coolcalmcollected
> Someone must've broken the holy seal
> 'Cause I know they're there, just like that fateful night
> Feeling colder
> I see
> I see
> I see the amulet of evil gods
youtube.com/watch?v=UfLjk4Bwar…
@Lana
Mercyful Fate - Kutulu (The Mad Arab Part II)
YouTubessa voit nauttia parhaista videoista ja musiikista, ladata alkuperäistä sisältöä ja jakaa kaiken ystäviesi, perheesi ja koko maailman kanssa.TempleofInanna (YouTube)
but… but… but… you’re using old models, on the wrong day, into a headwind, without proper PPE, before supper…
Tsssk. Keep up, loser.
And it demands ALL YOUR RAM!!!
ALL OF IT! 😂
It reminds me of something I learned from a cult survivor that they get you to submit to something you know is wrong. To demonstrate dominance and break people. Like Trump putting his team in wrong size shoes, or getting people to agree Biden didn’t win. This seems like that, including humiliation & hostility shown for non compliance.
Eyes go red, voice goes eldritch, the lights flicker.
Skynet starts firing.
this reminds me of a famous sketchshow... but comedy aside, the whole AI thing gets my goat.
youtu.be/MNuFcIRlwdc?is=Exjm0f…
Scottish Voice Recognition Elevator - ELEVEN!
YouTubessa voit nauttia parhaista videoista ja musiikista, ladata alkuperäistä sisältöä ja jakaa kaiken ystäviesi, perheesi ja koko maailman kanssa.ChanAlmighty (YouTube)
Nicole Parsons reshared this.
Thank you... I needed that. 😀
tbh I keep thinking these sorts of examples were "a long time ago" but really it is just doubling down on being confidently wrong about anything. Including instructing students.
I have no way of verifying this but I would also guess this isn't an edge case.
We're not going to need all the nonsense about walking in the desert and tortoises on their backs are we.
How do you spell s-e-v-e-n-t-e-e-n, Leon?!
You're in a desert, walking along in the sand when all of a sudden you look down and see a tortoise, Leon
It's crawling toward you
You reach down and you flip the tortoise over on its back, Leon
The tortoise is lying on its back, its belly baking in the hot sun, beating its legs trying to turn itself over but it can't. It can't without your help to spell seventeen Leon. But you're not helping
WHAT DO YOU MEAN, I'M NOT HELPING?
I mean you're not helping! How do you spell seventeen, Leon?!
Now you know why the funders of Project 2025 & the AI voucher school push, like Jeff Yass & Koch Network, adore AI so much.
AI education is a wonderful way to create an illiterate peasantry.
Think of the tax credits & lucrative no-bid government contracts for schooling going to Republican billionaires.
jacobin.com/2018/06/public-edu…
washingtonpost.com/politics/20…
jacobin.com/2023/03/jon-shelto…
jacobin.com/2024/07/culture-wa…
acrecampaigns.org/research_pos…
jacobin.com/2025/08/education-…
“Education Reform” Has Undermined Public Schools’ Popularity
School privatization efforts are making dangerous advances in states like Florida and Arizona. Neoliberal education reforms that have degraded public schools, from high-stakes testing to corporatized visions of education, are in part to blame.Jennifer C. Berkshire (Jacobin)
Nicole Parsons reshared this.
s - t - u - p - i - d
next- AI Bill clinton
@Lana

"When I was seventeen
It was a very good year
It was a very good year for small town girls
And soft summer nights
We'd hide from the lights
Under the village green
When I was seventeen...."
youtube.com/watch?v=TeDfgUvyKH…
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/It_Was_a…
It Was A Very Good Year (2008 Remastered)
YouTubessa voit nauttia parhaista videoista ja musiikista, ladata alkuperäistä sisältöä ja jakaa kaiken ystäviesi, perheesi ja koko maailman kanssa.Frank Sinatra - Topic (YouTube)
No 😡
No 🤬
No 🤡🔪
I like how she scolds him. solving problems with technology that weren't problems before technology.
we already knew how to teach people shit. this isn't a valid use case for ai.
Forgeting content for a second, still pretty amazing they can create live video animation with human facial emotions like that.
Tony de Peltrie, National Film Board of Canada 1985 was bleeding edge and took weeks of computing to render. A pionner in ability to add facial expressions.
Tony de Peltrie (1985) - Longest CGI animated film with speech (at the time)
YouTubessa voit nauttia parhaista videoista ja musiikista, ladata alkuperäistä sisältöä ja jakaa kaiken ystäviesi, perheesi ja koko maailman kanssa.Ultimate History of CGI (YouTube)
Jonathan Lamothe likes this.
reshared this
Jonathan Lamothe and Ryan Robinson reshared this.
This website uses cookies. If you continue browsing this website, you agree to the usage of cookies.



tom grzybow
in reply to Jonathan Lamothe • • •